娱乐所定义的一个明显的引理,但由于递归而无法证明

发布于 2025-02-05 14:07:51 字数 3618 浏览 1 评论 0原文

在这里,我定义了REGEXP表达式,并尝试证明一些明显的引理,这些引理定义为下面。

datatype ('v)regexp = ESet | LChr 'v| Concat "'v regexp" "'v regexp"|
                      Alter "('v) regexp" "('v) regexp"| Dot|
                      Star "'v regexp" | Plus "('v) regexp" | Ques "('v) regexp" | \<epsilon>         


fun ConcatRegexp::"'v regexp \<Rightarrow> 'v regexp\<Rightarrow> 'v regexp" where
  "ConcatRegexp r1 r2 = Concat r2 r1"

fun ConcatRegexp2::"'v regexp \<Rightarrow> 'v regexp\<Rightarrow> 'v regexp" where
  "ConcatRegexp2 r1 r2 = Concat (Concat r2 r1) r1"

fun renameDelta1 :: "('v regexp * 'v set * 'v regexp) set \<Rightarrow> ('v regexp => 'v regexp)  \<Rightarrow> ('v regexp *'v set *'v regexp) set" where 
    "renameDelta1 ss f = {(f q,v, f q')| q v q' . (q, v, q')\<in> ss}"

fun renameDelta2 :: "('v regexp * 'v regexp) set \<Rightarrow> ('v regexp => 'v regexp)  \<Rightarrow> ('v regexp  *'v regexp) set" where  
    "renameDelta2 ss f = {(f q, f q')| q q'.(q, q')\<in> ss}"

primrec trans2LTS :: "'v regexp \<Rightarrow> 'v set \<Rightarrow> (('v regexp \<times> 'v set \<times> 'v regexp) set * ('v regexp * 'v regexp) set)" where 
    "trans2LTS (LChr v) alp_set= ({(LChr v,{v},\<epsilon>)},{})"|
    "trans2LTS (ESet) alp_set= ({(ESet,{},\<epsilon>)},{})"|
    "trans2LTS (\<epsilon>) alp_set = ({(\<epsilon>,{},\<epsilon>)},{})"|
    "trans2LTS (Dot) alp_set = ({(Dot ,alp_set, \<epsilon>)},{})"|
    "trans2LTS (Concat r1 r2) alp_set =(renameDelta1 (fst (trans2LTS r1 alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp r2) \<union> (fst (trans2LTS r2 alp_set)),
                                        (renameDelta2 (snd (trans2LTS r1 alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp r2) \<union> {(Concat \<epsilon> r2, r2)}  \<union> snd (trans2LTS r2 alp_set)))"|
    "trans2LTS (Alter r1 r2) alp_set = (fst (trans2LTS r1 alp_set) \<union> fst (trans2LTS r2 alp_set), 
                                        snd (trans2LTS r1 alp_set) \<union> snd (trans2LTS r2 alp_set) \<union> {(Alter r1 r2, r1),(Alter r1 r2, r2)})"|
    "trans2LTS (Star r) alp_set = (renameDelta1 (fst (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp (Star r)), 
                                   (renameDelta2 (snd (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp (Star r))) \<union> {(Star r, \<epsilon>),(Star r,Concat r (Star r)),(Concat \<epsilon> (Star r), Star r)})"|
    "trans2LTS (Plus r) alp_set = ((renameDelta1 (fst (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp2 (Star r))) \<union> (renameDelta1 (fst (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp (Star r))), 
                                   {(Plus r, Concat (Concat r (Star r)) (Star r)),(Concat (Concat \<epsilon> (Star r)) (Star r),Concat (Star r) (Star r)),(Concat (Star r) (Star r), \<epsilon>),(Concat (Star r) (Star r), Concat r (Star r)),(Concat \<epsilon> (Star r), Concat (Star r) (Star r))}
                                    \<union>(renameDelta2 (snd (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp2 (Star r))) \<union> (renameDelta2 (snd (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp (Star r))))"|
    "trans2LTS (Ques r) alp_set = (fst (trans2LTS r alp_set),
                                   {(Ques r,\<epsilon>), (Ques r, r)} \<union> snd (trans2LTS r alp_set))"

称为ReflexNothold的引理定义为以下:

lemma reflexNotHold:"(r, r) ∈ snd (trans2LTS r v) \<Longrightarrow> False"
apply(induction r)
sorry

我首先尝试通过诱导证明这种引理。但是,由于递归,我无法解决四个子目标。

我不知道如何证明这种引理,任何帮助将不胜感激。

Here, I have defined the regexp expression, and try to prove some obvious lemma, which defined as below.

datatype ('v)regexp = ESet | LChr 'v| Concat "'v regexp" "'v regexp"|
                      Alter "('v) regexp" "('v) regexp"| Dot|
                      Star "'v regexp" | Plus "('v) regexp" | Ques "('v) regexp" | \<epsilon>         


fun ConcatRegexp::"'v regexp \<Rightarrow> 'v regexp\<Rightarrow> 'v regexp" where
  "ConcatRegexp r1 r2 = Concat r2 r1"

fun ConcatRegexp2::"'v regexp \<Rightarrow> 'v regexp\<Rightarrow> 'v regexp" where
  "ConcatRegexp2 r1 r2 = Concat (Concat r2 r1) r1"

fun renameDelta1 :: "('v regexp * 'v set * 'v regexp) set \<Rightarrow> ('v regexp => 'v regexp)  \<Rightarrow> ('v regexp *'v set *'v regexp) set" where 
    "renameDelta1 ss f = {(f q,v, f q')| q v q' . (q, v, q')\<in> ss}"

fun renameDelta2 :: "('v regexp * 'v regexp) set \<Rightarrow> ('v regexp => 'v regexp)  \<Rightarrow> ('v regexp  *'v regexp) set" where  
    "renameDelta2 ss f = {(f q, f q')| q q'.(q, q')\<in> ss}"

primrec trans2LTS :: "'v regexp \<Rightarrow> 'v set \<Rightarrow> (('v regexp \<times> 'v set \<times> 'v regexp) set * ('v regexp * 'v regexp) set)" where 
    "trans2LTS (LChr v) alp_set= ({(LChr v,{v},\<epsilon>)},{})"|
    "trans2LTS (ESet) alp_set= ({(ESet,{},\<epsilon>)},{})"|
    "trans2LTS (\<epsilon>) alp_set = ({(\<epsilon>,{},\<epsilon>)},{})"|
    "trans2LTS (Dot) alp_set = ({(Dot ,alp_set, \<epsilon>)},{})"|
    "trans2LTS (Concat r1 r2) alp_set =(renameDelta1 (fst (trans2LTS r1 alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp r2) \<union> (fst (trans2LTS r2 alp_set)),
                                        (renameDelta2 (snd (trans2LTS r1 alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp r2) \<union> {(Concat \<epsilon> r2, r2)}  \<union> snd (trans2LTS r2 alp_set)))"|
    "trans2LTS (Alter r1 r2) alp_set = (fst (trans2LTS r1 alp_set) \<union> fst (trans2LTS r2 alp_set), 
                                        snd (trans2LTS r1 alp_set) \<union> snd (trans2LTS r2 alp_set) \<union> {(Alter r1 r2, r1),(Alter r1 r2, r2)})"|
    "trans2LTS (Star r) alp_set = (renameDelta1 (fst (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp (Star r)), 
                                   (renameDelta2 (snd (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp (Star r))) \<union> {(Star r, \<epsilon>),(Star r,Concat r (Star r)),(Concat \<epsilon> (Star r), Star r)})"|
    "trans2LTS (Plus r) alp_set = ((renameDelta1 (fst (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp2 (Star r))) \<union> (renameDelta1 (fst (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp (Star r))), 
                                   {(Plus r, Concat (Concat r (Star r)) (Star r)),(Concat (Concat \<epsilon> (Star r)) (Star r),Concat (Star r) (Star r)),(Concat (Star r) (Star r), \<epsilon>),(Concat (Star r) (Star r), Concat r (Star r)),(Concat \<epsilon> (Star r), Concat (Star r) (Star r))}
                                    \<union>(renameDelta2 (snd (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp2 (Star r))) \<union> (renameDelta2 (snd (trans2LTS r alp_set)) (ConcatRegexp (Star r))))"|
    "trans2LTS (Ques r) alp_set = (fst (trans2LTS r alp_set),
                                   {(Ques r,\<epsilon>), (Ques r, r)} \<union> snd (trans2LTS r alp_set))"

The lemma called reflexNotHold defined as below:

lemma reflexNotHold:"(r, r) ∈ snd (trans2LTS r v) \<Longrightarrow> False"
apply(induction r)
sorry

And I first try to prove this lemma by induction. However there are four subgoal that i can not solve, because of the recursive.

I don't know how to prove this lemma, and any help will be appreciated.

如果你对这篇内容有疑问,欢迎到本站社区发帖提问 参与讨论,获取更多帮助,或者扫码二维码加入 Web 技术交流群。

扫码二维码加入Web技术交流群

发布评论

需要 登录 才能够评论, 你可以免费 注册 一个本站的账号。
列表为空,暂无数据
我们使用 Cookies 和其他技术来定制您的体验包括您的登录状态等。通过阅读我们的 隐私政策 了解更多相关信息。 单击 接受 或继续使用网站,即表示您同意使用 Cookies 和您的相关数据。
原文