在 Umbraco 和 Orchard ASP.NET CMS 之间做出选择
既然这两个系统都是基于 ASP.NET MVC 构建的，那么有人有处理这两个系统的经验吗？希望为朋友建立一个小型商业网站，最终将拥有一个在线商店。我读过很多帖子，但最近没有读过（自从 Umbraco 5 发布以来）。如果您有经验，只需寻找优点和缺点。任何与商务功能相关的东西也会很有帮助。谢谢。
Now that both system's are built on ASP.NET MVC, does anyone have any experience dealing with both? Looking to set up a small business site for a friend, that will eventually have an online store. I've read a lot of posts, but nothing recent ( since Umbraco 5 was released ). If you've had experience, just looking for pros and cons. Anything related to commerce functionality would be helpful as well. Thank you.
如果你对这篇内容有疑问，欢迎到本站社区发帖提问 参与讨论，获取更多帮助，或者扫码二维码加入 Web 技术交流群。
绑定邮箱获取回复消息
由于您还没有绑定你的真实邮箱，如果其他用户或者作者回复了您的评论，将不能在第一时间通知您！
发布评论
评论（4）
Orchard 是围绕 ASP.NET MVC 3 从头开始构建的。我个人更喜欢那个，因为它设计精良、非常活跃并且得到了 Microsoft 的支持。当然，完全免费。
如果您正在寻找电子商务解决方案 - 有一个新的、非常有前途的模块，称为 WebShop，以及 完整教程。
Orchard has been built from ground-up around ASP.NET MVC 3. I personally prefer that one, as it's well designed, very active and backed by Microsoft. And, of course, totally free.
If you are looking for e-commerce solution - there is a new, very promising module called WebShop, along with a full tutorial.
Orchard 非常动态，您可以用部件构建您的网站，电子商务模块将能够提供可以呈现为部分视图的部件。另一个自定义模块可以在其中注入其他视图。它的可扩展性非常好，我喜欢它。您可以仅允许商店管理员等访问管理面板。
我不知道以 ASP.NET MVC 为基础的 Umbraco，但我知道 Orchard 来自 Outercurve Foundation，我非常喜欢。
据我所知，只有一个真正的商务模块，但我不知道它是否有任何好处
Orchard 画廊 - Mageliawebstore
直接 Mageliawebstore
Orchard is very dynamic and u can build your site out of parts, a e-commerce module would be able to provide parts that can be rendered as partial views. Another custom module could inject other views in there. It's just very extensible and i like it. U can allow some access to the admin panel just for store administrators etc.
I don't know about Umbraco with ASP.NET MVC as base, but i know Orchard is from Outercurve Foundation which i like alot.
As far as i know there is just one real commerce module, but i don't know if it is any good
Orchard gallery - Mageliawebstore
Mageliawebstore directly
您好，不了解 Orchard，但 Umbraco V5 非常适合小型企业。您最近没有阅读很多帖子的原因是该架构是全新的。预计下个月会有大量文档。但是，如果您在后端使用为您呈现一些默认代码的创建模板对话框，您已经可以从获得大量信息的网站开始。
关于电子商务，我知道 UWebshop 和 UCommerce 已经在 Umbraco V5 之上构建其产品的下一个版本，因此预计很快就会有一个完全集成的电子商务解决方案。
Hi Don't know about Orchard but Umbraco V5 is ideal for a small business. The reason that you don't read a lot of post recently is that the Architecture is completely new. Expect a lot of documentation in the coming month. But you can already start with the site you get a lot of info if you are using the create template dialog in the backend which renders some default code for you.
Regarding Ecommerce I know the Package vendors of UWebshop and UCommerce are already building next versions of their products on top of Umbraco V5 so expect a fully integrated Ecommerce solution soon.
这是一个与时间相关的答案，但如果您想要一个基于 MVC 的 .NET CMS，那么此时您在两者之间唯一真正的选择是 Orchard。 Umbraco 5 提前退役，因此又回到了 Webforms，尽管从 4.10 开始 MVC 支持已经固定，而且我相信有一些模块也为 4.x 提供了一些 MVC 支持。另一方面，Orchard 是从头开始构建在 ASP.NET MVC 3 之上的，并且 结合了一些其他很酷的技术，使编写符合行业标准最佳实践的干净代码变得更加容易。
This is a time-relative answer, but if you want an MVC based .NET CMS then your only real choice between the two is Orchard at this time. Umbraco 5 saw an early retirement so it's back to webforms, although as of 4.10 MVC support was bolted on and I believe there are some modules out there that give 4.x some MVC support as well. Orchard, on the other hand, is built on ASP.NET MVC 3 from the ground up and incorporates a handful of other cool technologies that make writing clean code that adheres to industry standard best practices easier.