指针、二进制无效操作数和菜鸟

Question

[编辑：在底部添加矩形定义。] [编辑2：底部添加了 XYPoint 接口。]

我正在研究一种检查两个矩形是否重叠的方法。 （是的，我在 Kochan 的 Objective-C 编程 中做练习，而且我对此还很陌生。）当我编译这个时，错误消息是：“二进制 + 的操作数无效”。我在第一个 if 语句及其后面的 if-else 上得到它。

我想我对指针有疑问，但 Kochan 并没有谈论太多。

而且，如果我去掉这些行，该方法的其余部分就可以正常工作。并且相关变量都是浮点类型。

帮助？

此外，关于该方法的任何其他想法也将受到欢迎。 （比如，我怎样才能让代码行不那么长。就像我说的，这是新的痛苦。）

-(void) overlap: (Rectangle *)r2
{

overlapRectangle = [[Rectangle alloc] init];
leftRectangle = [[Rectangle alloc] init];
rightRectangle = [[Rectangle alloc] init];
lowerRectangle = [[Rectangle alloc] init];
upperRectangle = [[Rectangle alloc] init];

BOOL xIntersect = NO;
BOOL yIntersect = NO;


//  Test to see if the Rectangle contains, or is equal to, Rectangle b

if (origin.x <= r2.origin.x && origin.y <= r2.origin.y && (origin.x + width) >= (r2.origin + r2.width) && (origin.y + height) >= (r2.origin.y + r2.height) ) 
{
    overlapRectangle = r2;
}

//  Test to see if Retangle b contains, or is equal to, the Rectangle

else if (origin.x >= r2.origin.x && origin.y >= r2.origin.y && origin.x + width <= r2.origin + r2.width && origin.y + height <= r2.origin.y + r2.height ) 
{
    overlapRectangle = self;
}

//  I should add tests for triangles overlapping on three 
//  sides or overlapping  on two sides, but I'm not going 
//  to right now. Just learning objects and methods.


//  Test to see if rectangles overlap on the x-axis 
//  Current is an if, because I wanted to run the code below
//  to see if it worked, and it did. 

if (origin.x <= r2.origin.x)
{
    leftRectangle = self;
    rightRectangle = r2;
}
else 
{
    rightRectangle = self;
    leftRectangle = r2;
}

if (rightRectangle.origin.x + rightRectangle.width > leftRectangle.origin.x) 
{
    xIntersect = YES;
}



//  Test to see if rectangles overlap on the y-axis

if (origin.y <= r2.origin.y)
{
    lowerRectangle = self;
    upperRectangle = r2;
}
else 
{
    lowerRectangle = self;
    upperRectangle = r2;
}

if (lowerRectangle.origin.y + lowerRectangle.height > upperRectangle.origin.y) 
{
    yIntersect = YES;
}



//  If retangles overlap on both the x-axis and y-axis, 
//  determination of overlapping rectangle's origin, height, and width
//  and display same.

if (xIntersect == YES && yIntersect == YES) 
{
    overlapRectangle.origin.y = upperRectangle.origin.y;
    overlapRectangle.origin.x = rightRectangle.origin.x;
    overlapRectangle.height = lowerRectangle.height - (upperRectangle.origin.y - lowerRectangle.origin.y);
    overlapRectangle.width = leftRectangle.width - (rightRectangle.origin.x - leftRectangle.origin.x);


    NSLog (@"Your rectangles overlap.");
    NSLog (@"Rectangle: w = %g, h = %g", overlapRectangle.width, overlapRectangle.height);
    NSLog (@"Area = %g, Perimeter = %g", [overlapRectangle area], [overlapRectangle perimeter]);
    NSLog (@"Origin at (%g, %g)", overlapRectangle.origin.x, overlapRectangle.origin.y);
}

else 
{
    NSLog (@"Your rectangles do not overlap.");
}



[overlapRectangle autorelease];
[leftRectangle autorelease];
[rightRectangle autorelease];
[lowerRectangle autorelease];
[upperRectangle autorelease];

}

矩形定义：

// 接口，矩形类

@interface Rectangle : NSObject

{
    float width;
    float height;
    XYPoint *origin;

    // For overlapping calculations

    Rectangle *overlapRectangle;
    Rectangle *leftRectangle; 
    Rectangle *rightRectangle; 
    Rectangle *lowerRectangle; 
    Rectangle *upperRectangle; 
}

@property float width, height;

-(XYPoint *) origin;
-(void) setOrigin: (XYPoint *) pt;
-(void) setWidth: (float) w andHeight: (float) h;
-(float) area;        
-(float) perimeter;   
-(void) print;
-(void) translate;
-(void) overlap: (Rectangle *)r2;
-(void) draw;


@end

XYPoint 接口：

#import <Foundation/Foundation.h>

@interface XYPoint : NSObject
{
    float x;
    float y;
}

@property float x, y;

-(void) setX: (float) xVal andY: (float) yVal;

@end

Answer 1

您刚刚得到的可能是一个拼写错误：

// Test to see if the Rectangle contains, or is equal to, 
// Rectangle b

if (origin.x <= r2.origin.x && origin.y <= r2.origin.y && 
   (origin.x + width) >= (r2.origin + r2.width) && 
                         //^^^This is trying to add an XYPoint,
                         // which is an object, to a float.
   (origin.y + height) >= (r2.origin.y + r2.height) ) 
{
   overlapRectangle = r2;
}

// Test to see if Rectangle b contains, or is equal to, 
// the Rectangle
else if (origin.x >= r2.origin.x && origin.y >= r2.origin.y && 
         origin.x + width <= r2.origin + r2.width && 
                            //^^^Same thing.
         origin.y + height <= r2.origin.y + r2.height ) 
{
...

编译器应该告诉您您要求添加的类型是什么：

错误：二进制 + 的操作数无效（具有“struct XYPoint *”和“float”）

这就是关键。您只需将 r2.origin 更改为 r2.origin.x 即可添加两个浮点数。

至于线条的长度，您可以做两件事。您可以像我一样将条件的每个部分移动到不同的行，但最好为 Rectangle 创建几个方法来为您进行测试。这将使代码更具可读性，因此当您在六个月后返回代码并看到该行内容时：

if( [self containsRectangle:r2] || [self isEqualToRectangle:r2] ){

您将立即知道发生了什么。这里有一些建议：

- (BOOL)containsRectangle:(Rectangle *)otherRect {
    BOOL originBelow = ((origin.x <= otherRect.origin.x) && 
                        (origin.y <= otherRect.origin.y));
    float maxX = origin.x + width;
    float otherMaxX = otherRect.origin.x + otherRect.width;
    BOOL maxXGreater = maxX >= otherMaxX;
    Bfloat maxY = origin.y + height;
    float otherMaxY = otherRect.origin.y + otherRect.height;
    BOOL maxYGreater = maxY >= otherMaxY;
    return originBelow && maxXGreater && maxYGreater;
}

- (BOOL)isEqualToRectangle:(Rectangle *)otherRect {
    BOOL sizeEqual = ((width == otherRect.width) && 
                      (height == otherRect.height));
    return sizeEqual && [origin isEqualToXYPoint:otherRect.origin];

}

_{注意：我没有测试这些，只是根据 if 的条件将它们粘贴在一起，因此在使用它们之前请仔细检查它们。不过，我确实修复了拼写错误。}

请注意，我还在 XYPoint 上编写了一个方法，isEqualToXYPoint:;您也可以实现它，如果两个 XYPoint 的 x 和 y 相等，则返回 BOOL 。