magento VS magento 克隆 - 拥有成本
它性感，它令人沮丧，它昂贵？
基于可以模拟主要购物车功能的假设（购物车和目录规则等...）——Magento 还有什么其他特性？
如果实际上可以使用另一个 CMS 和熟练的程序员对其进行模拟，那么使用克隆的长期拥有成本是否会低得多，这难道不是理所当然的吗？
让我们面对现实吧，Magento 扩展的价格通常为 49-299 美元。相同的 Magento 扩展肯定是付费升级的。或者商店所有者将不得不向开发人员付费以定制 Magento 扩展 + 再次付费进行升级。
在我看来，几乎所有可以实施的补救功能，在 Magento 中都是付费的，而在“其他”中是免费的（或捐赠）。
所以我想问题是，如果使用另一个 CMS 作为框架，Magento 中的哪些内容是无法模拟的？
Its sexy, its frustrating, its expensive?
based on assumption that the primary cart features could be emulated (cart and catalog rules, etc...) --- what else is there about Magento that makes it excusive?
If it could in fact be emulated using another CMS and a skilled programmer, wouldn't it stand to reason that the long term cost of ownership would be far less with a clone?
Lets face it, Magento extensions are all typically $49-$299. Same Magento extensions are sure to be paid upgrades. Or Store Owner will have to pay devs to customize Magento extensions + pay again for upgrades.
Seems to me, almost every remedial feature that could be implemented, in Magento is paid and in "other" is free (or donation).
So i guess the question is, what is it in Magento that could not be emulated if another CMS was used as framework?
如果你对这篇内容有疑问，欢迎到本站社区发帖提问 参与讨论，获取更多帮助，或者扫码二维码加入 Web 技术交流群。
绑定邮箱获取回复消息
由于您还没有绑定你的真实邮箱，如果其他用户或者作者回复了您的评论，将不能在第一时间通知您！
发布评论
评论（2）
恭喜。您已经分析了市场并发现了您认为的机会。当您的克隆可供使用时请告诉我们。
不那么讽刺的是，你可以建造任何东西。 Magento 为您提供的是
一个系统，该系统已识别并成功执行了解决方案，许多其他购物车/框架无法解决的常见电子商务问题。是的，任何 Magento 解决的问题最终都可以用另一个 CMS 或编程框架来解决，但 Magento 已经解决了。
一个可扩展的系统，使其能够满足电子商务的未来需求（无论是什么需求），以及第三方开发人员以固定的统一费率解决这些问题的生态系统。
现在已经不是 1970 年了。没有哪个软件供应商能够解决您遇到的所有问题，而任何承诺解决的软件供应商要么是在撒谎，要么成本极高。 Magento 为您提供了一个平台和生态系统，可以帮助您解决这些问题，而不必依赖于现有的购物车供应商，因为他们在解决新问题上投入不多。
Congratulations. You've analyzed the market and discovered what you think is an opportunity. Let us know when your clone is ready for use.
Less snarkily, you can build anything. What Magento offers you is
A system that has identified, and successfully executed a solution for, many common Ecommerce problems not addressed by other carts/frameworks. Yeah, anything Magento has solved you can eventually solve with another CMS or Programming Framework, but Magento has already solved it.
A system that is extendable, allowing it to meet the future needs of Ecommerce, whatever they are and an ecosystem where third party developers are solving those problems for a fixed, flat rate.
It's not 1970 anymore. No software vendor is going to solve every problem you have, and any software vendor that promises to is either lying or extremely costly. Magento offers you a platform and an ecosystem that can help you solve these problems, and not be reliant on the existing cart vendors who aren't too invested in solving new problems.
我们目前正在从自定义编程网站迁移到 magento。我们目前使用的网上商店的拥有成本非常高。它不属于我们所有，只有一家供应商可以帮助我们。他们可以随心所欲地收费。
使用开源购物车的 USP 是可以更换程序员、主机等。很容易找到自由程序员和扩展提供商。
如果 magento 克隆完美无缺并且有良好的支持，那就太好了。我关注CS-shop，因为我认为它而不是magento。论坛中的一些请求已有 2 年历史，但仍然不是包的一部分。
我们对目前为止我们的 magento 网站花费的相当高的成本并不满意，但我们会留下来。开源（magento）的最大问题是扩展之间的冲突。当某些东西不起作用时，这是谁的错？
我会再次选择magento吗？知道真正的成本不是免费的，我会考虑使用完整的 ERP 软件解决方案，其中包含会计和内置所有内容，只需微笑着支付月费即可。转折点是我知道我可以随时打电话寻求帮助。
We are currently moving from a custom programmed site to magento. The cost of ownership has been very high for our currently used webshop. Its is not owned by us and only the one supplier can help us. They can charge whatever they want.
The USP of using a open source cart is the possibility to change programmer, host etc. It is easy to find freelance programmers and extension providers.
A magento clone would be great if it was flawless and backed up by good support. I follow CS-shop as I considered it instead of magento. In the forum some requests are 2 years old and are still not part of the package.
We are not happy with the rather high cost our magento site has cost us so far, but we will stay. The biggest problem with open source (magento) is conflicts between extensions. Whos fault is it, when something is not working?
Would I choose magento again? Knowing the real cost is not free I would consider a full ERP software solution with accounting and everything built in and simply pay the monthly fee with a smile. The tipping point is knowing I can call anytime and get help.