iPhone UI 设计：“确定”按钮或没有“确定”按钮
我有强迫症，喜欢视觉上干净的设计。
我的应用程序中有一个弹出窗口，告诉用户有错误。
我在整个弹出窗口（大约 200x100 像素）上制作了一个清晰的按钮，以便用户只需触摸通知即可将其关闭。
但我担心用户可能不知道您只需触摸弹出窗口即可关闭，并且会疯狂地寻找“确定”按钮。
你们认为 OKAY 按钮是必要的还是一个巨大的透明按钮覆盖通知就足够了？
注意：整个通知实际上看起来像一个按钮，因为有圆角和一些按钮类似的边框。
I am compulsive and like visually clean designs.
Theres a pop up in my app that tells the user that there's an error.
I made a clear button over the entire pop up (about 200x100 px) so the user can just touch the notification to dismiss it.
But i'm afraid the user might not know that you can just touch the pop up to dissmiss and would go crazy looking for the "OKAY" button.
Do you guys think the OKAY button is necessary or is a giant clear button overlaying the notification good enough?
note: the whole notification actually looks like a button because of rounded corners and some button like borders.
如果你对这篇内容有疑问，欢迎到本站社区发帖提问 参与讨论，获取更多帮助，或者扫码二维码加入 Web 技术交流群。
绑定邮箱获取回复消息
由于您还没有绑定你的真实邮箱，如果其他用户或者作者回复了您的评论，将不能在第一时间通知您！
发布评论
评论（4）
无论用户可能误解什么，他们都会误解（只需看看一些排名较低的应用商店评论即可）。
因此，除非它使您的用户界面混乱和/或使事情变得更加混乱，否则明确指示如何摆脱或超越弹出窗口肯定会减少用户困惑的机会。
Whatever users can misinterpret, they will (just look at some of the low ranked App store reviews for examples).
So, unless it clutters your UI and/or makes things even more confusing, a clear indication of how get rid of or move beyond your popup will certainly reduce the chances for any user confusion.
我喜欢你的设计理念，但我会选择“确定”按钮。世界上可能有人不理解它并指责你的应用程序。
或者您省略该按钮，让通知在 5 秒后自行消失。
I like the idea of your design, but I would go for an OK button. There might be people in the world who don't understand it and blame your app.
Or you leave out the button and make the notification disappear by itself after, say 5 secs.
或者你可以走微软的路：
- 添加“确定”按钮
- 添加一个较小的复选框，标题为“不要再问我”
- 当单击“确定”按钮并标记复选框时，打开一个附加对话框，通知用户“确定”按钮将不再显示，但他们可以清除首选项菜单中的设置
- 按照描述创建首选项菜单
现在谁说微软的 UI 很糟糕？
Or you could go the Microsoft way:
- add the "Okay" button
- add a smaller checkbox with the caption "don't ask me again"
- when the okay button is clicked and the checkbox is marked, open an additional dialog notifying the user that the Okay button will no longer be displayed, but that they can clear that setting in the preferences menu
- create the preferences menu as described
Now who says Microsoft suck at UI ?
您应该使用“确定”按钮。不仅用户会更加熟悉，而且苹果的审批流程也不会有任何问题。根据审阅者的不同，他们可能会因为不符合人机界面指南而拒绝该应用程序。
You should use the OK button. Not only will it be more familiar for users, but you won't have any problem with Apple's approval process. Depending on the reviewer they might reject the app for not conforming to the Human Interface Guidelines.