我遇到了一个困境,我们的客户关系部门被请来寻求 UI 方面的建议,但我强烈反对……尽管我根本不认为自己是设计师。虽然我一直直言不讳地表达了我对此的不同意见,但我还是被要求指出设计标准,以证明我所说的是正确的,而客户关系部的人完全错误。
下面是一个模型,我试图论证飞机、船和沙发的图标(是的,我也没有选择这些)属于页面标题(与徽标相同的区域)而不是在页面的内容区域。有人可以帮助我指出一些有助于证明我的观点的东西吗?
非常感谢,
Greg Andora
I have a dillema where our client relations department has been brought in for advice on UI and I vehemently disagree with it...even though I don't consider myself a designer at all. While I have been vocal about my disagreement about it, I've been asked to point to design standards to prove that what I'm saying is correct and that the guys in Client Relations are flat out wrong.
A mockup is below, I'm trying to argue that the icons of the airplane, boat, and couch (ya, I didn't choose those either) belong in the header of the page (same area as the logo) and not in the content area of the page. Can anybody please help me by pointing me to something that helps prove my point?
Thanks a lot,
Greg Andora
发布评论
评论(2)
人们询问图标的用途这一事实确实凸显了设计问题。并且可能违反可见性原则:
然而,这并不意味着将图标移动到其他地方就可以解决问题。
The fact that people have asked what the icons are for does highlight a design problem. And could go against The visibility principle:
However, that doesn't mean moving the icons anywhere else solves the problem.
如果只是为了装饰,图标可以粘在任何地方,只要不影响用户体验即可。
至于标准,几乎没有。设计更多的是一种艺术表达而不是工程。
If it's only for decoration, the icons can stick anywhere, provided it doesn't hinder the user experience.
As for the standards, there are hardly any. Design is more of an art expression than of engineering.